Behind the Scenes: The Judging Process of Our Web Design Awards

Published on
September 16, 2023
Behind the Scenes: The Judging Process of Our Web Design Awards

Get an insider's look into the meticulous judging process of our Web Design Awards. From initial screening to core evaluation criteria, find out how we recognize and celebrate excellence in web design.

All posts
Subscribe to our newsletter
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

The world of web design has expanded exponentially over the past few years. From stunning layouts to intricate functionalities, a well-designed website has become an essential asset for any successful business. But how do we recognize excellence in web design? Our Web Design Awards serve this purpose, providing a platform for designers to showcase their talents and win recognition in the industry. In this article, we're pulling back the curtain to give you a sneak peek into the intricate judging process that sets our awards apart.

Initial Screening

Technical Merit

Before we dive into the aesthetics or user experience, the first line of assessment is technical merit. We use various tools to scan for things like load time, accessibility, and mobile responsiveness. A poorly optimized website, no matter how beautiful, could be eliminated in this first round.


We also ensure that websites submitted adhere to the guidelines and rules of the competition, including ownership, publication date, and other specifics. Websites found to be in violation of these standards are disqualified.

The Judging Panel

Our judging panel is composed of a diverse group of professionals, ranging from experienced web designers and developers to digital marketers and UI/UX experts. This multiplicity of perspectives ensures a balanced evaluation that takes into account all crucial aspects of web design.

Core Criteria

Visual Impact

The initial impression is crucial. Websites that grab attention through innovative design, cohesive color schemes, and impactful visuals score high in this category.

Functionality and Navigation

Our panelists don’t just look at the surface. They dig deep into the site's structure, evaluating how easy it is to navigate and how well it accomplishes its intended purpose.

Content Relevance

Good design is not just about form; it’s also about function. Sites need to provide valuable, relevant content to their users. This is analyzed rigorously to ensure that the design serves the content, rather than overshadowing it.

Creativity and Originality

While it’s often easier to follow trends, we highly value original and innovative design. Points are awarded for unique features and solutions that set a website apart from the rest.

User Experience

From the intuitiveness of the design to the emotional impact it has on visitors, the overall user experience is weighed carefully in the judging process.


In a world that is increasingly digital, it’s crucial that websites are accessible to everyone, including people with disabilities. Accessibility is not an afterthought but a core criterion in our evaluation.

Scoring System

Each criterion is assigned a score, typically on a scale of 1 to 10. The scores from each judge are then averaged for each criterion for every submission. These average scores are then summed to form a total score for each website.

Feedback Loop

Not only do entrants receive their scores, but they also get valuable feedback from the judges. This feedback can provide insights that are instrumental for designers and developers in enhancing their future work.


The judging process of our Web Design Awards is designed to be as comprehensive, impartial, and rigorous as possible. It is not just about determining winners; it’s also about setting industry standards and inspiring a whole new generation of web designers. We believe that behind every great website is a brilliant mind, and through our meticulous judging process, we aim to celebrate this marriage of creativity and technology.

So the next time you marvel at a website that won one of our awards, you'll know just how much scrutiny and thought has gone into that accolade. Happy designing!

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the purpose of the Web Design Awards?

right arrow

The Web Design Awards serve the purpose of providing a platform for web designers to showcase their talents and gain recognition in the industry. They aim to recognize excellence in web design and set industry standards.

How is the judging process for the Web Design Awards structured?

right arrow

The judging process consists of several stages: initial screening, compliance and the judging panel.

Who makes up the judging panel for the Web Design Awards?

right arrow

The judging panel comprises a diverse group of professionals, including experienced web designers, developers, digital marketers, and UI/UX experts. This diverse perspective ensures a balanced evaluation.

How are websites evaluated in the Web Design Awards judging process?

right arrow

Websites are evaluated based on core criteria, creativity, user experience, content, and animation. Each criterion is scored on a scale of 1 to 10 by judges, and the average scores are summed to form a total score for each website.

Do entrants receive feedback on their submissions in the Web Design Awards?

right arrow

The entrants will receive the scores based on the 3 core criteria.

Our blog

You Might Also Like

10 website awards every agency should know about
March 23, 2024

10 website awards every agency should know about

Dive into the world of web design excellence with our exploration of the top web design award platforms. From the innovation-focused FWA to the prestigious Awwwards, this article unveils where digital creativity meets recognition. Discover how winning these coveted awards can elevate your web presence, validate your expertise, and open doors to unparalleled opportunities. Whether you're a freelancer, a studio, or an agency, learn how these platforms can spotlight your talent and propel your digital footprint to new heights. Ready to stand out? Let’s unravel the path to becoming an award-winning digital creator.
 iArk Boutique: Greece's Award Winning Digital Agency
February 24, 2024

iArk Boutique: Greece's Award Winning Digital Agency

In an era where digital presence is synonymous with a brand's identity, iArk Boutique Digital Agency stands as a beacon of innovation and excellence in Greece's digital landscape. Renowned for its award-winning designs and strategic digital marketing solutions, iArk transforms businesses by blending aesthetics with functionality, creating websites that not only captivate but also engage users on every level. With a legacy of over fifteen years, their expertise spans web design, development, social media, and beyond, making them the ideal partner for those seeking to elevate their online presence.
Casa di Solare Website Wins Web Design Awards - Site of the Month
March 1, 2024

Casa di Solare Website Wins Web Design Awards - Site of the Month

The Casa di Solare website, a beacon of digital design excellence, has been awarded a prestigious web design accolade, underscoring its innovative approach and exceptional user experience. This honor is attributed to the creative genius of Nathan Riley, co-founder and lead designer at Unseen Studio, whose collaboration with Casa di Solare resulted in a masterpiece of functionality and aesthetic appeal. The site's distinctive identity is further enhanced by the custom Solare font, meticulously crafted by Nikolas Type, marking a pinnacle of design collaboration and technical prowess. This award not only celebrates the artistic and technological achievements of the Casa di Solare website but also sets a new benchmark for web design excellence.
Beginner's Guide to Winning a Website Design Award
February 13, 2024

Beginner's Guide to Winning a Website Design Award

In the quest for excellence in web design, earning an accolade from a reputable platform such as Web Design Awards can significantly elevate a designer's profile and work. This beginner's guide emphasizes the importance of understanding award criteria, prioritizing innovation, and focusing on user experience to create standout digital experiences. By integrating creativity with functionality, paying meticulous attention to detail, and articulately presenting the story behind the design, aspiring winners can navigate the competitive landscape of web design awards. With these strategies, designers are equipped to craft websites that not only captivate and engage but also earn the prestigious recognition they deserve, marking their creations as benchmarks of excellence in the digital realm.
Responsive Web Design: A Must-Have for Modern Websites
January 24, 2024

Responsive Web Design: A Must-Have for Modern Websites

In the ever-evolving digital landscape, responsive web design stands as the cornerstone of website success. As the mobile revolution continues to shape user behavior, providing a seamless experience across all devices is no longer an option but a fundamental necessity. Responsive design ensures that your website not only adapts to different screen sizes but also excels in user experience, SEO rankings, and cost-effectiveness. It future-proofs your online presence, staying relevant in the face of emerging technologies. Moreover, responsive design can transform your website from a mere online presence into an award-worthy masterpiece, setting the stage for excellence in today's highly competitive digital arena.
Critiquing Award-Winning Website Designs: A Professional Perspective
December 9, 2023

Critiquing Award-Winning Website Designs: A Professional Perspective

We embark on an insightful journey into the world of exemplary web design. This article offers a deep dive into the criteria that elevate a website to award-winning status, emphasizing the seamless blend of creativity, functionality, and user experience. Through a detailed analysis, we explore how cultural and artistic elements are intricately woven into these designs, not only to enhance aesthetic appeal but also to forge a deeper connection with diverse audiences. The piece culminates in a compelling conclusion, highlighting how these websites transcend traditional design boundaries, melding art, technology, and user-centric principles to set new benchmarks in the digital realm. This article is not just a critique; it's a celebration of innovation and a blueprint for future excellence in website design.